Why is Xu Wenbing's statement about the five flavors to the five organs different from what is found in the Yellow Emperor's Classic of Internal Medicine?
Why is Xu Wenbing's statement about the five flavors to the five organs different from what is found in the Yellow Emperor's Classic of Internal Medicine?
Xu Wenbing's talk about the five flavors and five organs is actually not contradictory to the Neijing.
1. Take salty, although salty into the kidneys, but not the more salty the better, on the contrary, the Nei Jing cloud "taste too salty, big bone gas labor, short muscle, heart gas suppression", "more food salty, then the pulse coagulation sobbing and change color". Therefore, over-eating salty food, to the kidney self-injury, so it is said that "diarrhea kidney", which also reflects the Chinese medicine is not enough, emphasizing the point of view of moderation. For example, food is good for the stomach, but it does not mean you can eat and drink.
2. Take bitter, bitter into the heart, bitter belongs to the heart flavor. At the same time, from the perspective of the five elements, bitter can produce sweet, sweet can produce pungent, pungent can produce salty, that is, Jin Sheng Lishui, from the perspective of tonifying the heart to achieve the purpose of tonifying the kidneys, so that the bitter can indirectly tonify the kidneys.
3. Other theories can also be understood in this way, such as excessively bitter diarrhea of the heart, or acid diarrhea of the liver, excessively sweet diarrhea of the spleen, sweet can nourish the liver, acid can nourish the lungs ......


No cure how to say anything, the theory to be verified, the theory from the practice, can not be separated from the practice!
The five organs and five flavors are divided into body and use. Separation of body and use is the key.
Some of Xu Wenbing's views are from Auxiliary Tips.
Read the Yellow Emperor's Neijing about the five organs and five flavors of the relevant discussion, sometimes it is to describe its body, sometimes it is to describe its use, distinguish the body of the flavor use, it is possible, to crack the Neijing on some of the discussion seems to be inconsistent confusion.
The five flavors are more systematically described in the Fu Xing Xie. Learning Fu Xing Xie is one of the keys to solving the secrets of typhoid and the secrets of Nei Jing.
Xu Wenbin: is an amateur! He can only look at the hustle and bustle.
Five elements are mutually reinforcing, water and fire, then in turn water is small equivalent to replenish fire, fire is small equivalent to replenish water. I don't know if I understand this logic, but if I don't, I don't need to learn it.
The effect of salty flavor is to run down, that is, to use up the water to use up the water to run. So it is equivalent to the use of kidney water, is the diarrhea of the kidney, diarrhea of the kidney is equivalent to tonifying the heart, so salty is diarrhea of the kidney and tonifying the heart.
In turn, the effect of bitter flavor is dryness, which means using fire. Using the fire is equivalent to diarrhea of the heart, and draining the fire is equivalent to tonifying water, so bitter flavor is diarrhea of the heart and tonifying the kidneys.
You don't have to learn if you can't figure it out!
"The five flavors that enter are sour into the liver, pungent into the lungs, bitter into the heart, salty into the kidneys, and sweet into the spleen."
Usually in accordance with the five flavors into the five viscera to regulate, is to mobilize the internal organs of the self-healing function, so to choose the most direct and obvious flavor of the internal organs of the impact. Therefore, the main theory of therapeutic conditioning is the five flavors into the five organs.

Is it supposed to be based on the chanting of the Nei Jing, the Treatise on Typhoid Fever? Because the Chinese medicine big maga, explain Chinese medicine, is to read the scripture, and the monk read the scripture is no difference? The main thing is to read the scriptures, is the Chinese medicine big maga? The main thing is that you do not recite the scriptures, Chinese medicine big maga people say that you have no respect for Chinese medicine, to put it more harshly, is to sell the ancestors? If Chinese medicine practitioners recite the scriptures again, Chinese medicine will be extinguished by those who recite the scriptures! Japan does not recite scriptures, the sales of proprietary Chinese medicines only 90% of the world's share. China's Chinese medicine big maga, every day read the scriptures, only 3% of the share. So China's Chinese medicine big maga every day read the scriptures, bragging, blowing "Neijing", "Typhoid" how great? Trillion dollar industry, let Japan take away. If the Chinese medicine big magazines, and recite the sutra every day, bragging every day, Chinese medicine, no one will believe in Chinese medicine, pCms sales in the world is only 0%.
The so-called Chinese medicine practitioners do not necessarily have read books like Huangdi Neijing, after all, Chinese medicine practitioners nowadays are basically intentional, unintentional has been very few and far between
Based on the Yellow Emperor's Classic of Internal Medicine
This question and answer are from the site users, does not represent the position of the site, such as infringement, please contact the administrator to delete.