1. Home
  2. Question details

Are all Chinese medicine practitioners who prescribe "big prescriptions" not good Chinese medicine practitioners?

Are all Chinese medicine practitioners who prescribe "big prescriptions" not good Chinese medicine practitioners?

You can't say whether you are a good Chinese medicine practitioner according to the size of your prescription. In the sixties and seventies, there was a traditional Chinese medicine doctor outside of Andingmen in Beijing. He was nicknamed Su Trip. He prescribed a large prescription for one visit. He prescribed a lot of medicines with good results. He was a good TCM doctor.

The Yellow Emperor's Classic of Internal Medicine (HUNDI NEIJING) has a certain standard for the number of flavors in a prescription, that is, the system of generosity, but thirteen, and the largest prescription in the Treatise on Miscellaneous Diseases of Typhoid Fever (TCHM), the turtle armor decoction pill, has 23 flavors, and there are still large prescriptions in the classics, so judging whether or not a Chinese medicine practitioner is good is not to judge by the size of the prescription. In my opinion, when a Chinese medicine practitioner prescribes a prescription, he should base on the result of the identification of the disease, and the prescription should have a clear direction, so as to correct the bias of the disease by the bias of the prescription, if the disease is complicated, he can prescribe a bigger prescription, but he must guide the bias of the qi and blood in order to treat the disease, so that even though the prescription is big, it is still a good prescription, and the doctor is also a good doctor. If the identification of inaccurate, to the symptoms to prescribe, headache, add some chuanxiong, knee pain, plus hyssop, without identification, headache, foot, not to the overall view of Chinese medicine to guide the yin and yang, qi and blood tends to the standard of peace, east a hammer, a hammer, just a pile of drugs, no direction, the eyebrow and beard, the primary and secondary, so that the big prescription will not work, such a Chinese medicine is not good, is good or not is open to question.

Now the external rehired old doctor old Chinese medicine to rely on traditional Chinese medicine to eat, he does not prescribe a large number of treatments do not allow a patient to be treated over and over again, he how to eat it? Many patients we admitted patients are told to eat three pairs of drugs five doses of medicine on the good, and those old Chinese doctors are saying that you have to eat half a year medicine three months medicine ...... for this kind of problem is not good to judge him with morality, can only say that the technology is what kind of and morality is not related, we should have a standard of assessment, and the use of medicine with a more It is an economic burden for the patient and a resource drain on society.

You drive a lot and either you don't understand or you're just shooting the breeze. The cure is based on luck.

The Chinese medicine practitioner himself requires that the medicine be simple and specialized, and that every medicine prescribed must be able to explain the reason for its use, and that it should be directed to the vital point. Never prescribe more than one flavor.

Even if multiple symptoms in the body, but also to distinguish between the first table after the inside, table symptoms in, absolutely most will not work in.

If the weakness is extreme, it is also necessary to first explain why the body should be supplemented first, and then solid viscera, so that the disease does not pass through. When the blood and qi recovered, the opportunity to attack.

Anyone who cannot reason is a half-wit. Or they have gone astray and followed the wrong teacher.

People, from the very beginning, have to learn the classics. One wrong step leads to another wrong step. If the theories you accept are inherently faulty, how can you help the world?

In 2003, because I grew up with a weak spleen and stomach, often diarrhea to an individual downstairs to sell drugs, upstairs to see a doctor's hospital. After an old Chinese doctor pulse, pull open the drawer and take out a large sheet of paper single, not a common hospital prescription list, began to down densely manipulated full of a prescription list, the checkout spent several hundred, when the heart is not comfortable heartache ah! That is a month's salary seems to be a few hundred dollars, no way. I thought I could cure the problem is also worth it, the results ate half a month did not see a little improvement. I was so angry that I threw away all the remaining two-thirds of the medicine, and I have never been to that hospital since.

One-sidedly say ...... prescribe "big prescription" is not a good Chinese medicine, that is unfair, completely misinterpreted. The purpose of a doctor is to prescribe the right medicine for the right condition. Selfishness ......💰 money ...... is another story.

Thank you, with the size of the formula to judge the doctor's inferior, I do not agree, I am accustomed to prescribe a large formula, as the saying goes, medicine such as soldiers, as a doctor should not be uniform, the heavy hand you do not use, how do you do, that is a quack, according to the patient's condition, do not take into account the personal gains and losses, the patient is the first place, the patient can be relieved of the pain of the patient one day, why do you drag him seven or eight days, of course, also need to be divided between the people! Of course, it is also necessary to distinguish between people, those high-ranking officials and dignitaries, except, not to mention, we understand!

For the owner of this statement, perhaps too absolute and difficult to comply with the normal logic of Chinese medicine theory of treatment of disease.

Chinese medicine theory of symptomatic treatment, some diseases, only a single prescription of a single flavor of Chinese herbs, can be the medicine to the disease, while some diseases, need a combination of several flavors of Chinese medicine, in order to be able to medicine to the disease, in addition to a number of serious and complex and difficult diseases, it is necessary to several or even dozens of flavors of Chinese herbs of the effective combination of the patient in order to give a difficult and miscellaneous diseases given to the elimination of the patient, so the Chinese medicine practitioners given to patients to treat the disease, each with their own tricks, as long as the ability to As long as he can treat the patient's internal or external diseases, he is a 'good herbalist' in the patient's mind, otherwise he is not a versatile herbalist, but a 'wild herbalist' whom the patient does not trust.

I have seen Chinese medicine practitioners who prescribe large prescriptions, usually more than thirty flavors, and there are good results. However, I do not appreciate, Chinese medicine is biased, some also have to consider the amount of medicine too much on the five viscera and six bowels whether there is damage? Sickness comes like a mountain, go sick like a silk. New disease can use heavy medicine, old disease is suitable for light medicine, heavy disease is suitable for a tiny amount of medicine, of course, back to the sun to save, life-threatening with heavy medicine is another story. I do not advocate the use of generous cure, I advocate the use of Chinese medicine practitioners to cure diseases with high prices, the key to see the efficacy. I treat high blood pressure that cannot be lowered by antihypertensive drugs, and the price of Chinese medicine is one thousand to two thousand dollars a month. I treat a baby born 13 days has been diarrhea, three days I charge more than five hundred. Some people say I am black, but in fact I am much kinder compared to western doctors. Go to the western hospital to rescue a day is usually around ten thousand dollars. There is no comparison, there is no harm! Chinese medicine treatment is cheaper. But the key is, Chinese medicine treatment should focus on the effect, only catch the mouse is a good cat.

It should be a dialectical treatment, and the medicine should be added or subtracted according to the symptoms.

This question and answer are from the site users, does not represent the position of the site, such as infringement, please contact the administrator to delete.

Related Questions