1. Home
  2. Question details

Is it scientific for hospitals to be so carefully divided into specialties, treating each part of the body individually?

Is it scientific for hospitals to be so carefully divided into specialties, treating each part of the body individually?

Definitely not scientific.

Medicine should be a holistic view, where healing is a strategic and tactical fit.

While localized refinement is good, a global view is more important.

Diving headlong into the smallest details without looking at the big picture often results in small victories and the loss of the big picture.

Science, but not in line with human function, assembly line can say not science? Assembly line production is science, assembly line like cure ...... will not dare to ...... compliment. Like a repairman, only repair a small part of the division of labor, the toxic side effects of Western medicine hurt other parts of the human body to find other related repairman to go.

The hospital's careful division of departments allows for more precise treatment of diseases, and each doctor has a general understanding of diseases in other parts of the human body in addition to an in-depth study of his or her specialty. Interdisciplinary diseases can be consulted by specialists from related departments for advice on diagnosis and treatment, and can be referred to other departments for treatment if necessary. A well-known medical practitioner is very knowledgeable, and specialists in internal medicine are well versed in dermatology, neurology, cardiology, respiratory, gastroenterology, endocrinology, nephrology, and other types of diseases, as well as a variety of difficult and rare diseases. For example, Prof. Zhang Xiaoqian of the Union Hospital is such a great person.

The constant subdividing of medical treatment in Western medicine's hospitals is a characteristic of scientific mechanical reductionism, which is very scientific, but unethical. In the spirit of scientific atomism, Western medicine constantly alienates the dynamic human life form into a static model, deconstructs it continuously, and alienates it into different levels of atomic entities, such as from organs to tissues, from tissues to cells, and from cells to molecules. For each level of micro-forms that Western medicine deconstructs the human model to, a large number of different kinds of atomic entities are created for different parts of the body, each of which may need to be re-constructively recognized, resulting in a large number of sub-disciplines. As more and more types of atomic entities are studied in Western medicine, the sub-specialties of hospital care become more and more subdivided. As the sub-specialties continue to grow, the object of each department's treatment becomes more and more distant from the whole of human life, and its efficacy and safety become more and more difficult to be guaranteed. The continuous division of western hospitals is the embodiment of the mechanical reductionism of science, but also a reflection of the gradual plight of western medical diagnosis and treatment theory, which is not an advancement of the medical level, but a complete regression.

Those who say that modern medicine does not have a holistic view, buy a physiology book and read it first. Don't you think it's funny that a bunch of people who haven't gone to medical school for a day spend their days trying to discredit modern medicine?

Unscientific.

This is the thinking of Western medicine. Because Western medicine is anatomy, all you see are parts of the human body. Therefore, Western medicine is divided into very fine departments, so fine that you don't even know which department to hang up when you are sick. When a patient involving several specialties arises, there will be a consultation.

The last time I ate a bone and got it stuck in the pearly fossa of my esophagus, because half of it was stuck in my throat and half in my esophagus, the ENT doctor at Huaxi called the Gastroenterologist on his computer to come over for a consult, and the two of them were pulling their hair out on WeChat. The Gastroenterologist said most of it was stuck in the throat and it was an ENT condition. The ENT doctor said that some of them are stuck in the pyriform fossa of the esophagus, which has something to do with your gastroenterology department. After half a day of bullshit, the Gastroenterologist just wouldn't come and left the ENT doctor to fend for himself.

So Western medicine treats the headache and the foot.

Chinese medicine believes that the human body is an organic whole, any place out of order, are related to the five viscera and six bowels.

A good TCM doctor should be a general practitioner. Even surgical and dermatologic diseases are related to the disorders of the five organs and six bowels of the human body.

That's why a good CMP should be a general practitioner.

Anyone who cuts up the human body to cure a disease is unscientific.

In ancient times, Bian Magpie, Zhang Zhongjing and Hua Tuo were all general practitioners. Bian Magpie knew how to scrape bones and heal wounds, how to catch bones with willow, and Hua Tuo even knew how to perform craniotomies. He was going to perform craniotomies to treat Cao Cao's headaches, but Cao Cao thought Hua Tuo was trying to kill him, so he killed Hua Tuo in a fit of rage. After Cao Cao killed Hua Tuo, no more Chinese doctors dared to perform open-heart surgery.

This new crown epidemic has also proved that Chinese medicine is the most advanced and perfect medicine. No matter what new or old viruses you have, there is no difference between the old and the new. Conditioning the five organs and six bowels of the human body and letting the body's righteousness to overcome it, the new crown pneumonia will be cured.

Those who say this must be lay people, or people who have not undergone a systematic education in modern medicine.

Doctors from the day of undergraduate education, learning is very comprehensive content, from the anatomy, physiology, pathology, pharmacology, pathology, physiology and other related courses, are the whole body system for a complete education, including the connection between these horizontal relationships, as well as different tissues and organs of the same between the cells, cell walls, cell membranes, the cell nucleus, as well as the operation of which the blood and lymph, this Everything is analyzed and judged according to the whole of a person.

As for the very precise division of various departments in hospitals nowadays, some hospitals even divide orthopedics into 7 to 8 departments, which can only show that the development of science and technology is becoming more and more sophisticated, and the study of each small localization is becoming more and more thorough, thus resulting in the emergence of such a fine division, which can only be a good thing rather than a bad thing for the patients.

Of course it must be recognized that a doctor is no more brilliant. It is also impossible for him to be proficient in all of them, otherwise this is not a human being this is a god. For large general hospitals, consultation between different departments is a common thing, so when there are problems related to other departments, simple problems can be dealt with naturally, because these things have been learned, and more complex problems, you can ask the relevant doctor's department to conduct a consultation with the doctor. From there, we can discuss and decide on the best course of treatment. This is something that is done every day, so how can we say that we do not have a holistic view? How can we say that each part is treated separately?

胆心综合征,肝肾综合征,肝肺综合征,肺性脑病,脑心综合征,多脏器功能衰竭,ards等等等等,随随便便就能举出一大堆彼此之间不同器官组织之间相互影响的疾病,怎么能说单独对一个部分进行一致呢?

The person who said this must be someone who has not been educated in modern medicine, if you if you simply do not understand, I will not say anything, if you are in order to sell your so-called set of nebulous theories, the so-called holistic view of the theory, then it is better to go back to read first, do not come out to let out let people laugh. [I want to be quiet] [I want to be quiet]

It is not scientific to determine the cause of the disease by division! Holistic concept! Treatment can be specialized in separate disciplines!

The organs in the human body are all interactive cycles, less that there will be problems there! Mashing out directly due to a problem at one point creates a new cascade of symptoms. That's not scientific.

This question and answer are from the site users, does not represent the position of the site, such as infringement, please contact the administrator to delete.

Related Questions