Is it credible for TCM practitioners to say that they don't need to know what disease you have to cure you anyway?
Is it credible for TCM practitioners to say that they don't need to know what disease you have to cure you anyway?
Credible, because Western medicine treats the symptoms, Chinese medicine treats the root cause, treating the symptoms is to accurately find out where the bad, the bad place for targeted treatment. The treatment of the root is based on the pathogenesis of your disease to your disease to treat, that is, often heard a phrase is the internal disease external treatment, external disease internal treatment, that is, according to you this symptom is caused by what and medication treatment. Specific example is, when a person because of anger caused by fire, such as red eyes, mouth and tongue sores and other symptoms, Western medicine treatment means will use anti-inflammatory pain treatment. Take anti-inflammatory drugs or hang a bottle. And Chinese medicine will be based on you are the kind of fire caused by, give you take a cattle Huang Shangqing pill can be cured. Western medicine you use his research and development of medical equipment is very difficult to find is due to the internal organs of the six internal organs caused by fire, while the Chinese medicine at a glance know. Specific people why angry will cause the five internal organs on fire and performance in the five senses, the specific reasons and processes here I will not speak here, speak more than understand, the key to the Western medical equipment you can not check this pathogenesis, others will say that I'm talking nonsense. You think I have a point, just point a concern, I will explain to you more instruments can not explain the problem and phenomenon!
For example, this new crown pneumonia, Chinese medicine practitioners do not need to know, as long as you know is the epidemic poison, is it cold or heat or damp heat cold damp, and then according to the basic symptoms and signs will be able to come up with a treatment prescription.
Foolish men and women will believe, for example, if you have a cracked head fluke or thallium poisoning, add up Shennong Bianzhi Hua Tuo Zhang Zhongjing to whatever Li Master Deng Master Ni Master, and give them another 3,000 years, they don't know what that is, and rely on traditional Chinese medicine, they can only wait for death.
Chinese medicine is different from Western medicine, which has names, instruments and a set of specialized theories that can be applied to diseases.
Chinese medicine on the disease does not have a name, there is no instrument, by looking and sniffing, the formation of images in their own brain to argue the symptoms, many people do not understand Chinese medicine, looking for Chinese medicine, the medicine that is caught and do not understand, (and even say that headache and foot, stomach ache wipe two hundred and two of the bad words), so do not believe in Chinese medicine, so do not look for Chinese medicine to see a doctor.
You're trying to make Chinese medicine practitioners take the blame for the fraudulent claims made by charlatans by grafting them onto Chinese medicine practitioners. You have to give the TCM practitioner the source of this statement.
In fact, except for fools, one look at the title, I know that you are black Chinese medicine gang, want to play a clever to make up Chinese medicine just.
This statement is still based on, not necessarily all right, in fact, Chinese medicine focuses on both the disease and the evidence, mainly based on the evidence to treat. There is the evidence to use is medicine. Chinese medicine is often related to the name of the disease and evidence, such as jaundice is both the name of the disease, but also a direct description of the symptoms. The evidence of jaundice is divided into yin yellow and yang yellow, of course, there are subdivided. Chinese medicine, whether it is hepatitis B or hepatitis C, or cirrhosis, where jaundice occurs according to the patient's evidence. The treatment is based on the patient's evidence. Chinese medicine treatment is like peeling onions. Layers of peeling, the emergence of the evidence has, the disease will be light. Of course, Western medicine says whether the objective indicators of the disease are normalized after treatment, while Chinese medicine first says whether the patient's self-feeling is good. (clinical cure). Of course, Chinese medicine is also the use of modern technology testing, and now patients take the initiative to test the indicators, often monitoring. Then there is the current and last year's coronary pneumonia. Chinese medicine treatment, no matter what the virus, is based on the emergence of the evidence and carry out therapeutic activities, typhoid fever theory of the six meridians identification, warming science of Wei Qi Ying blood dialectic, San Jiao identification, as long as the identification of accurate, appropriate medication, the efficacy is very good. Some diseases after hospital treatment. Improvement, but always can not do a complete eradication, there is no special way, Chinese medicine can sometimes be resolved. There is a eighty-four-year-old patient vomiting fecal impassability, urinary impassability, hospital catheterization enema, the symptoms have been reduced, but has not been able to solve the whole, a stop catheterization, enema and impassable, help in traditional Chinese medicine, I identify for the large Chaihu Tang evidence, large Chaihu Tang plus subtractions before and after serving six doses of feces and urine through the, do not vomit, can eat, the original bed-ridden. Get up. Very heavy patients, the age has been old, rhubarb soup has a flavor of rhubarb, on the flavor of rhubarb whether to use, with the risk of not using the effect is not good. Consideration again and again finally used, before serving two payments have rhubarb did not appear side effects, the effect is very good, after Lei's several payments have rhubarb, received good results. The treatment method of Chinese medicine has really given people the impression that they do not pay much attention to the name of the disease, but they can really cure your disease.
As a Chinese doctor with decades of medical experience, I can responsibly say that Chinese medicine can indeed cure a large number of diseases, difficult and complicated diseases. However, there is no such thing as a cure-all for all diseases as claimed by the questioner. We Chinese medicine practitioners will also evaluate ourselves objectively and face up to our own inadequacies. Cure all diseases' will never come out of any doctor's mouth. All living things have their own growth rules, life is a life, the grass grows in the fall, and there is always a time when the tortoise lives for 10,000 years. Even if there is a panacea, the fate of God, no one has the power to change. Only those with ulterior motives will come up with such bizarre topics.
Western medicine said:As long as you have money, any disease can be cured? Do you believe it? Western medicine also said: to save lives and serve the people, do you believe it?
Let's start with the conclusion. The claim is plausible.
Because the diseases that TCM says it doesn't know are just not known by Western medicine's names, it has a system of its own.
Theoretically, the principles of treatment in Chinese medicine, although based on experience, adhere to a set of systemic doctrines. It operates according to a control-feedback approach, which in a certain sense has something in common with the black-box theory of modern science. Therefore, in the social life of thousands of years, Chinese medicine has become a powerful weapon in the fight against disease. Protect the health of a powerful weapon.
To put it in layman's terms, traditional Chinese medicine looks at the disease. Traditional Chinese medicine starts with appearances, that is, symptoms. Based on experience, the symptoms are treated. For example, a person has symptom A. He is cured with medicine B in the quest. Ten people come after them, all with symptom A, all with medicine B, and all are cured.
In this way, the relationship between symptom A and medicine B is established. As for the reason behind the formation of A, what ingredients are in medicine B, and what is the mechanism by which the action occurs, traditional Chinese medicine does not look into it. This is, to some extent, similar to the black box theory and approach.
Of course, Chinese medicine has his limitations. It is only when he is combined with Western medicine, which has a disaggregated research methodology, that he can play a better role.
The principle of wholeness in Chinese medicine and the principle of searching for causality in Western medicine can complement each other. We can learn from each other.

This statement is correct, Chinese medicine doesn't care what disease you have, as long as you have symptoms, you can use Chinese medicine to regulate it.
Chinese medicine does not cure diseases, but treats the symptoms manifested by the diseases. Like the Sun disease, Shaoyang disease and Yangming disease in the "Treatise on Typhoid Fever", all of them have their own symptoms, and Chinese medicine is to regulate them with Chinese medicine according to these symptoms.
If there are no symptoms, just a mere name of the disease, there is no way for Chinese medicine to treat it, just like the new coronary pneumonia now, and it does not matter what kind of virus, as long as there are symptoms manifested, it can be dialectically treated by Chinese medicine.
Some people also dispute that Chinese medicine practitioners do not even know the virus, so how can they treat neocoronitis? In fact, Chinese medicine practitioners do not need to know what virus is present, as long as there are symptoms manifested, they can treat it, and the reality is the same.
This question and answer are from the site users, does not represent the position of the site, such as infringement, please contact the administrator to delete.