1. Home
  2. Question details

Who do you think ultimately loses out when doctors and patients are tense and distrustful of each other?

Who do you think ultimately loses out when doctors and patients are tense and distrustful of each other?

The biggest victim is the patient! Mistrust between doctors and patients, resulting in doctors protective medical behavior, increase the cost of medical care for patients, take one of my personal experience, last year's Spring Festival on the first day of the New Year I took my son to Nanjing to play, he ate bad things, stomach pain at night, 1:00 a.m., we went to Children's Hospital to see the emergency room, in front of a child fever, a family of parents and grandparents of the six or seven people, yakking to the doctor, saying what you Must look good, our family is a baby, you are so young can do it, do not delay, the child's grandfather also said to your director to come and so on, there is no little respect and trust, the doctor bowed his head and opened a lot of fever-related tests, let them go to the payment of the bill, the back of the several patients because of the influence of that family group and the doctor is not very cooperative, the doctor simply asked a few questions on the opening of the examination, in fact, I understand him very well! I understand him very well, because in the early morning of the first day of the Lunar New Year, other people are in the family reunion or sleep, but he is still busy, and met with patients who do not trust him, who feel bad. When it was our turn, I smiled kindly at him and said, "Hello, I'm sorry to bother you in the early morning of the first day of the Lunar New Year, I can't help it that my son's stomach hurts a lot", he froze, looked at us for a second or two, and laughed happily, really laughed happily, and inquired about his son's condition in detail, and then carefully auscultated the heart, lungs and abdomen and performed abdominal palpation, palpation, and then the abdomen was palpated. Abdominal palpation, palpation is also very careful to cover the hand hot, and finally opened three tests (routine blood, urine, stool routine), after the test took the results back to the doctor where, is to see that a large family in the quarrel, said what open this much check, is to commission what, the doctor replied to these tests you can not do, sign on the medical record on the line, the results of the results have no words honestly go to the check! The doctor replied that these tests you can not do, just sign the medical record. And we, to the doctor to see the results, the doctor said nothing, is to eat bad stomach, acute gastroenteritis, originally do not need to transfuse, but you still have to travel tomorrow, if you believe me, injected once, I said, OK, listen to you. We spent less than ninety dollars that day. The next day my son was happy to continue traveling. In fact, you give the doctor trust and friendly, the doctor dares to give you trust clinic, otherwise, you don't even trust him, why should he take the responsibility for you? Many diseases, you have 1% treatment hope, and you only give the doctor trust he dares to take the risk for your treatment, so that the doctor to 1% of the hope may turn into 99% success, if you do not trust the doctor, and even take this as blackmail blackmail, then, that 1% will become 100% death. So, smile a little more and trust a little more when you visit your doctor, and do yourself a favor.

The patient suffers anyhow, because the social environment is so bad! People are often victimized and have no place to go for justice!

When the doctor-patient relationship is strained, it is always the patient who ultimately loses out.

In medical activities, patients are always vulnerable compared to doctors, and the absolute imbalance of information determines the inferior status of patients.

Don't expect the patient's choice of doctor to solve the problem; the patient's choice is nothing more than a nurturing touch.

In the past two days, three doctors from the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology of the First North University Hospital were beaten by patients and their families for no apparent reason. The cause of the incident was probably that the mother wanted a caesarean section, but after the doctors examined the patient, they thought that she did not meet the indications for a caesarean section and recommended a normal delivery.

Originally, the cost of normal delivery is lower, the recovery is faster, and the development of the baby is better, which is beneficial to the patient. But the doctor to pay longer time, income is also down, is a "thankless" thing, why the doctor's good intentions were treated as a donkey's liver and lungs? The ultimate reason is that patients do not trust doctors.

Who's losing out on this one?

The doctor in question clearly lost out.Orbital and mandibular fractures, multiple soft tissue injuries and manifestations of post-traumatic stress syndrome. While short-term wounds can heal, I'm afraid the psychic trauma will remain for life.

Did the patient and family in question lose out?You can't see it on the surface, but you don't know when you've actually suffered a loss. I don't know what kind of courage they have to remain in this hospital for surgery. Of course the doctors and nurses won't intentionally harm you, but you know how their attitudes have changed since then. Although the medical profession does not allow the existence of a "blacklist". But I believe that every doctor and nurse has a "blacklist" in their heart.

Are fellow physicians losing out?We are just spectators, flat out angry and shouting for a few days, but we can't do anything about where things are going. After the incident, we should do what we do, but our hearts are even colder. Some people resign from their jobs in frustration, and those who stay have more and more heart, and pay more attention to how to protect themselves.

Did the general public lose out?You feel like you're staying out of it, but you're actually the ones who are losing the most.

The good doctors are sad and have lost their work ethic.

Great doctors change careers and quit.

The best students don't want to study medicine anymore.

Doctors will no longer give you the most specialized, best-for-you advice. Instead, they listen to you on everything.

Doctors will also stop taking great risks to save your life, because sickness and death areIt should, and unsuccessful resuscitation is punishable by a beating.

If patients and doctors treat each other as enemies from the moment they walk through the hospital doors, who do you think really loses out?

Life is like a mirror; if you smile at it, it will smile at you.

Being kind to your doctor is being kind to yourself.

Welcome to follow Dr. Cheng's 100 high and focus on the health issues around you.

Doctor-patient relationship, this topic said more will fall into a kind of generalization of the lack of, will let a person have a sense of powerlessness, doctors and patients should have been intimate comrades in arms, their common enemy is only one, that is, the disease, but, I do not know from when onwards, doctors and patients gradually tend to tense the relationship between doctors and patients in the past the kind of harmony that exists in the general relationship between doctors and patients no longer exist.

Tension between doctors and patients, the most fundamental reason is that doctors and patients have lost the most basic trust between doctors and patients, doctor-patient trust is the core of the doctor-patient relationship, there is no mutual trust, there is no mutual understanding, but also the loss of mutual tolerance, I have said in the article "What are the main problems affecting doctor-patient relationship? In my article "What is the main problem affecting the doctor-patient relationship?", I once said that understanding, tolerance, trust, is the most important issue affecting the doctor-patient relationship, mutual trust, in building a harmonious doctor-patient relationship is how important.

So, with the loss of the most basic trust between doctor and patient, who will ultimately lose out? The doctor? Or the patient? Or rather, who will ultimately be harmed by the lack of trust between doctors and patients?

My answer is that a doctor-patient relationship that has lost trust ultimately hurts both the doctor and the patient, and there are no winners under a strained doctor-patient relationship!

If the patient loses trust in the doctor, he will be skeptical about all the treatments, programs, and suggestions of the doctor in the process of diagnosis and treatment, and will even go from skepticism to questioning, to resistance, to confrontation, and to hostility. For example, if the doctor gives him a test or a treatment, he will wonder, "Is it necessary?" "Is it effective or not?" "Is the doctor trying to make more money out of me?" and so on. etc., he will not cooperate with the treatment, and in extreme cases, he will scold the doctor, which will inevitably affect the medical consultation and treatment and the final medical results. For example, a patient with chest pain to the emergency department of the hospital, the doctor gave him an electrocardiogram, myocardial ischemia manifestations, the doctor proposed to recommend further examination, but the patient did not trust the doctor, and afraid of spending money (suspect that the doctor wants to make more money), refused the doctor's advice, the result is that three days later, the patient suddenly died of heart attack. Cases like this abound, really, if you do not trust the doctor, sometimes the ultimate "loss" is their own.

Patients have lost trust in medical practitioners and, likewise, can cause harm to them. In recent years, there has been a proliferation of medical disputes and incidents of medical violence, many of which are due to patients (family members) losing trust in medical personnel and eventually resorting to violence.

The patient's loss of trust in the provider can be detrimental to both the provider and the patient, and the provider's loss of trust in the patient can be equally detrimental to both the provider and the patient.

Doctors do not trust patients, the most important performance is to take conservative, preventive treatment, not to have merit but no faults, risky tests do not dare to do, risky surgery do not dare to do, risky treatments do not dare to do, "big check" is the doctor has lost trust in the patient under a kind of self-protection and precautionary helpless, some of the risky but very effective treatments and surgeries also because the doctor does not trust the patient and give up, so it will inevitably harm the interests of patients and aggravate the conflict between doctors and patients. Risky but effective treatment means and surgery also because the doctor does not trust the patient and give up, so, will inevitably damage the interests of patients, exacerbating the conflict between doctors and patients. The doctor due to take conservative treatment led to the damage of the patient's interests, will inevitably expand the rift between doctors and patients, enhance the mistrust between doctors and patients, so, back to the first level, the patient's mistrust of the doctor, and ultimately, the same will hurt the doctor himself.

The trust between doctors and patients is two sides, mutual, the damage to the interests of one party, ultimately will inevitably hurt the other party, because, doctors and patients were originally comrades in arms, they only have a common enemy, that is - disease!

Have a little more trust in each other!

Do you trust your doctor? Do you trust your patients? Please leave a comment if you have any views, and remember to click a like if you agree with this article.

Promoting medical science, dissecting the doctor-patient relationship, and telling doctor-patient stories, please follow me: anesthesia superman man of steel.

I don't lose out anyway, because I never go to that

Learning and inheriting folk herbal medicine, self-medicating and self-governing when sick, saving money and worrying.

Tension between doctors and patients, and ultimately both lose, the patient does not trust the doctor, can not get accurate treatment delay is their own condition, the doctor does not trust the patient, fear, lack of humane and lead to disputes affect their reputation and future, so ultimately a lose-lose situation, and the patient as a disadvantaged party, the loss of face will be relatively large.

Behind the repeated injuries to doctors is a lack of trust and respect between the two sides

Although the state has strengthened the control of "medical malpractice", but the "injury to doctors" incidents are still repeatedly staged, alarming, behind the scenes more because of the bloodshed caused by doctor-patient disputes, the root of which is a lack of trust and respect for the doctor, the patient believes that the doctor has not Patients think that doctors are not doing their best and not doing a good job, and they think that doctors are charging money indiscriminately and are inhumane. Doctors do not trust the patients, but also fear, afraid of their own safety, afraid of patients running away to be deducted, afraid of patients to conceal the disease is infected and so on.

Behind the repeated blackout of doctors is the helpless blood and tears complaint of patients

We can see, on the network has a lot of "black doctor" people, pay close attention to their remarks can be insight, behind the scenes, in fact, many are helpless blood and tears complaints, suffered excessive medical care, indiscriminate prescribing of medicines, indiscriminate charging, put the disease dragged on, etc., the problem of difficult and expensive to see a doctor has never been solved, there is no hate in the world for no reason, part of the doctors' As a part of the doctor's does hurt people's hearts, and doctors as an important part of the doctor-patient relationship, bear the brunt, naturally bear the wrath of the people's blood and tears complaints.

Both doctors and patients are victims, and both suffer if they don't address the trust issue

Although the State has strengthened the punishment of "injured doctors", but the fundamental point is still how to solve the problem of trust between doctors and patients. Still need to have measures at the level of trust, such as the introduction of commercial insurance, the real separation of medicine, so that the doctor and money is no longer linked to the doctor specializing in medical care, by the insurance to be responsible for paying the bill; fee transparency, drug traceability and so on;

Increase the doctor's ethical guidance, and actively shape the reputation and focus on medical ethics; patients to guide the rationality of medical treatment, science and education of patients to break down information barriers, improve the quality and create a harmonious environment, etc., from a multi-dimensional approach to gradually approach the top, and gradually restore the trust of doctors and patients is the right way.

Welcome to follow the common exchange of learning healthy posture

There is actually no big data on the claim that the doctor-patient relationship is strained, and we cannot say that a certain individual case is a common phenomenon.

In the era of increasingly standardized management, the doctor is also so, now the doctor's attitude does not know how many times better, I remember when I was a child, are afraid to go to the hospital, small illnesses are given to the doctor's brutal attitude scared into a big disease.

In fact, the professional ethics of doctors nowadays are still quite high. I have accompanied my mother to the hospital many times, and the doctors' medical ethics and attitudes are all very good, so I still recognize the doctors.

When dealing with the doctor-patient relationship, I think we must first trust the doctor, we go to see the doctor, if you do not trust the doctor, then it is difficult for you to have a good result, so in the end, the ones who lose out are themselves.

Of course, we can't rule out individuals who have poor medical ethics in life, and such doctors will eventually smash their own rice bowls.

The doctor-patient relationship is now strained, and this is mainly due to two reasons:

Firstly, hospitals and health care workers are seriously irresponsible and violate the relevant regulations, even to the extent of violating medical routines and doctors' professional ethics, causing serious financial losses or undue harm to patients. This leads to patients suing everywhere and harboring resentment.

Secondly, the patient's side is unreasonable, even to the blackmail, so that the original normal medical behavior has become a tool to make money, intensifying the demand for hospitals and doctors to compensate and take responsibility. The doctors and hospitals have no peace of mind, headaches.



A few years ago, I represented a health center in a medical dispute case, a patient's condition is very serious, because of the distance from the major hospitals, so the first to the township health center for resuscitation. The township health center tried its best to save the patient's life, but in the end, it could not save the patient's life.

This is supposed to be a normal medical phenomenon, and there is no fault on the part of the hospital for being active and treating the patient. The patient died of failure to rescue, also due to his own disease.

However, the patient's family believed afterwards that it was the doctor's medical fault that led to the patient's death, so they sued everywhere and went to the hospital to disrupt the normal medical order without reason.

Later, after identification, the hospital side did not have any responsibility. But the patient's family is still not convinced, sued to the court. The first trial, the second trial, finally although the hospital are the same to win and end, but because the lawsuit cost too much manpower and material resources, so the leadership of the hospital had said to me face to face: in the future, such as this critical patients, are not admitted, through let them go to other hospitals for treatment, so as to save the trouble.

If this is really the case, I think the increase in doctor-patient disputes and medical conflicts can only be unfavorable to the patients, and it is the patients who will ultimately suffer. Therefore, in the occurrence of medical disputes must be sensible, reasonable and legal solution, do not be unreasonable, not to mention bad blackmail. Otherwise, the bad luck is still the patient side.

I'm a doctor, and here's a bloody reality for you. How the doctor-patient relationship is victimizing the average patient. I vaguely remember the nationwide verbal assault on last year's vaccine incident, when I was reminded of the tragic events that followed the U.S. vaccine mistrust crisis event a couple of decades ago. As expected, some parents refused to take the vaccine, some manufacturers are not willing to produce the vaccine, the current nationwide shortage of just DPT everywhere, around the real example of a child in the hospital vaccine did not have DPT, as a result of the family of two children have been infected with whooping cough, and now also in the right to defend. This is an example, but this is definitely not the end, because this is only the beginning! Real examples do not accept refutation.

This question and answer are from the site users, does not represent the position of the site, such as infringement, please contact the administrator to delete.

Related Questions