1. Home
  2. Question details

Are some Chinese medicine practitioners in the private sector who treat people for free considered to be practicing illegal medicine?

Are some Chinese medicine practitioners in the private sector who treat people for free considered to be practicing illegal medicine?

It shouldn't count, it should be promoted to use what you have to serve the people!

Yesterday, there is a uremia patients, online to me to help, he is like this: Mr. Lao, I am only thirty-eight years old this year, on the parents, under the study of the child, I am the pillar of my family ah, the family is a rural area, the hospital can not afford to see ah, to dialysis, kidney transplantation, how do I do ah? At that time, my heart like a cat scratch, if I give him a prescription, I do not have a license illegal ah, I had to answer, I said I am just a folk Chinese medicine, I am afraid that I have more than enough power ah, and do not have your first-hand information, you send your condition, I can give you a reference. I see you in the neighborhood Chinese medicine hospital to find a good doctor to see. I can't help it, I don't dare to go out for free, I have no place to give out my kindness.

Some folk Chinese medicine practitioners treat people for free, is it considered illegal to practice medicine?

Thank you all! Not having a license to practice medicine is illegal! In our day and age we have entered the age of law and everything is done according to the law.

In the past, there is a saying that "a long time to become a doctor", but only in the experience of touching some of the medicinal properties of the medical theory, if you want to get a license to practice medicine is still a hundred thousand miles away. Examination of medicine is the theory of the examination, only experience without theory how can be called a doctor? Therefore, even if you get the license to practice medicine, you do not have clinical experience, but to save people still need a period of time to work hard.

I have treated a case of cirrhosis, three cases of mastitis, a case of breast cancer patients, and rheumatoid edema, but also some hospitals did not find the cause of several cases of patients, (just a cold plague). Patients looking for me I also treated, but I do not have a license to practice medicine, but also is not a local doctor. Although all cured, but also took great risks, until today have palpitations, that is to save lives? No, it was a crime. What is the difference between a mistake and a murderer? Not to eat salt without thirst is not to use their own life but to save life? Saving lives, and their own luck closely linked, good luck is to save lives, down on their luck is to kill people, this is a never subvert the truth.

Of course it is against the law, the law is the yellow line of the system, but not against the patients. The question is where will the hospitals get the money for their equipment when the whole country is like this? Who will feed the health care workers when they are all out of work?

I was thinking, Western medicine to the patient before the knife why the family to sign, frankly, is a contract of life and death, the best life, death is not legally responsible. So western knife cut dead people no one sued, sued also useless, who asked you to sign the word oh?

To revitalize Chinese medicine, why can we not follow this contractual approach of Western medicine? The original meaning of medicine is to aim at efficacy, and living patients are certificates and word of mouth. Assuming that a standard is set to give a person a contribution award if he cures a hundred cancer patients, who cares whether he has drunk ink or not, and whether he has a certificate or not, how can he do so? How simple it is.

Chinese medicine is originally the concept of medicine, different regions, different learning different repeated experience, different perspectives of understanding. Many experts and scholars can not crack the problem, in a certain place some people seem to be pediatrics, due to too many reasons not to cure the disease to save lives as a mission. I think that if we liberalize Chinese medicine, the world must be cancer-free in the near future.

Why do we need Western medicine to tie up Chinese medicine? If we do not untie Chinese medicine, the inheritance of national treasures is just empty talk, and we all say that this is not the case.

Chinese medicine is the cultural heritage of the Chinese nation for thousands of years, the crystallization of the wisdom of survival. The treasure of the nation, the treasure of treasures.

Note: the text is not centered, the words are not appropriate, do not have to spray, as a countryman sleepwalking Xing hand scribbles.


I twice had a toothache, went to the hospital for a few days of treatment could not get well, and then found a farmer uncle without a license, gave a small packet of powdered herbs, put the powder on the teeth around, ten minutes to stop the pain, he did not charge a penny. He did not charge a penny. The uncle was a familiar face, and he did not specialize in practicing medicine, but kept a small stock of medicines at home for the convenience of those who needed them, so was this situation considered an illegal practice of medicine? Nowadays, dogmatism is prevalent and everything is said to be evidence, which is harmful to people. In the future, when we see bad people doing harm, if we do not have the relevant documents, can we stand up and stop them?

If free medical treatment is an illegal practice, then the Chinese people are not far from extinction. Because this is already a human problem, not a legal problem, the law has exceeded the natural ecological law, everyone has the obligation to maintain the ecological law.

Folk Chinese medicine colleagues, for the people to do good is not a crime. As a folk Chinese medicine after the passing of the world, a good hand of inherited Chinese medicine technology, if you meet someone sick, the patient begged you to see the disease, in this emergency situation, regardless of whether there is no physician's license, you can save, provided that you are diagnosed in the patient, first of all, you have to diagnose the cause of the disease, don't misdiagnose and misdiagnose the cause of the disease, there is a physician's license or no physician's license, as long as you can treat the patient, no license is also not a defense, if You put the patient's diagnosis and medication wrong, the patient is bad, you just have a physician's license is also responsible, not to mention that you do not have a physician's license, then you are even more sinful.

Therefore, traditional Chinese medicine families do not have any physician's qualification certificate at all, and they also have the secret skills of ancestral Chinese medicine. In the old society and the early liberation period, as long as the family of traditional Chinese medicine practitioners, there is no connection with the qualification certificate. The family of traditional Chinese medicine practitioners is all about morality, ethics, goodwill, kindness and skill, and does not use the qualification certificate to measure the level and future of a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner!

Of course, the reform changes in the present era, to use the diploma to measure whether you are a doctor or not, to use the qualification certificate to control whether you are a doctor or not; do not use the medical technology to assess whether you are qualified enough to even recognize as a doctor. Nowadays, the management department takes diploma as a shield and clinical medical technology as a pass! Medical students have a diploma, in the examination of the master's degree, in the examination of the doctorate, in the examination of the post-doctoral examination, the examination to the end of the age of more than 40, all kinds of senior qualifications, but the clinical medical technology skills, do not know at all. Therefore, they are assigned to work in the unit, relying on the laboratory auxiliary inspection for the body, and will not see the disease at all, not to mention the condensation of difficult diseases; this is the situation of today's Chinese medicine. Western medicine can be practiced according to this method, but Chinese medicine, do not use this method to practice medicine, Chinese medicine, if the diploma to measure, do not use the inheritance and apprenticeship clinical experience in Chinese medicine, to teach future generations, that graduated from all the regular [mediocre Chinese medicine].

Of course, everyone understands that there are no rules, and the new era has laws and regulations to recognize a skill. By which we when the doctor, more to respect the discipline and abide by the law, with the qualification certificate to prove that you are not a Chinese medicine practitioner. All things, to be analyzed in detail: like the ancestral folk Chinese medicine people, are passed down to the technology, do not need a diploma to measure the level of Chinese medicine. Of course, the inheritance of folk Chinese medicine people also read a lot of ancient books, ancient books in the original history of the society also set up the examination room, but not issued a qualification certificate, in the original history of the society of all walks of life are technology-based, do not need a diploma to recruit people to do things, in order to be technically competent in order to be recruited to do your job. Inheritance of Chinese medicine apprenticeship, but also in the prestigious Chinese medicine family, inheritance out of the apprenticeship, before they can independently go to the folk to see the Chinese medicine disease. There is a saying, from the teacher is not high, the student is not good. If the old Chinese medicine practitioner you reapprentice to is not famous in the local area, then you learn the medical skills are also not high. If you worship a prestigious old Chinese medicine practitioner, then the Chinese medicine techniques you learn must be real and special Chinese medicine techniques.

Therefore, learning Chinese medicine is a study of clinical experience, do not put diploma in the first place. No one is invited to have a certificate without skills, and there are skills without certificates that can be passed on to eight parties. I hope that the future generations of Chinese medicine scholars, to balance the heart to the still, benevolent and charitable with credentials and skills, is a [character and learning] good Chinese medicine Langzhong. Chinese Medicine Practitioner Lu Wenwu

Folk Chinese medicine practitioners to cure the sick for free, one, medical ethics, two, relief of the poor, three, a heart for the people, why illegal, questioner, can you do it. You give me shut up, learn more good. Post Comment: not open-minded at heart.

Today it is this license, that license, so that the old man fell to the ground no one dares to save, dare to help, in the past a fire, the whole village with their own appliances to run to the fire, fight the fire after each go. Is it illegal to fight a fire without a license? I do not have a license to save a burned by the electricity, if you wait for a license to come, would have been killed, if I did not save, I should also seat in jail?

Nowadays, there are indeed self-educated and ancestral Chinese medicine folk doctors (bioprescription, acupuncture, cupping, massage, bone-setting and bone-setting, etc.) who use their spare time to treat patients suffering from difficult and complicated illnesses and traumatic injuries free of charge, and some of these illnesses are still very effective using Chinese medicine treatment methods! However, in the event of treatment errors, resulting in accidental death of the patient, his family to pursue the responsibility of the doctor, the civil and the court will be recognized as the illegal practice of medicine, illegal doctors should bear all the responsibility, which has nothing to do with the free or charge! In other words, when a Chinese medicine doctor relieves a patient's condition or cures him completely, he can only get a "thank you", and the good people will even give him some gifts to show their appreciation! In short, if a patient is cured, he is a good doctor; if he is killed, he is a Chinese medicine practitioner practicing illegally.

This question and answer are from the site users, does not represent the position of the site, such as infringement, please contact the administrator to delete.

Related Questions