1. Home
  2. Question details

Chinese medicine is inferior to Western medicine, losing not in efficacy but in standardization, do we agree?

Chinese medicine is inferior to Western medicine, losing not in efficacy but in standardization, do we agree?

Disagree. Chinese medicine is not inferior to Western medicine, and Chinese medicine is still far superior to Western medicine in many aspects. Chinese medicine is marginalized by the fight is lost in the system, lost in the industrial society people used to pay for the concept of big industry. For example, this year's new crown pneumonia epidemic, the beginning of the Chinese medicine was sidelined on the intervention, Chinese medicine intervention after the transfer rate dropped significantly, but the vast majority of media reports are focused on the rescue of critically ill patients, is because of the prestige of the Western medicine rescue more media effect, while Chinese medicine seems to downplay the treatment process is not so media effect.

The diagnostic and therapeutic means of Chinese medicine is to look, smell and examine, the medical theory of Chinese medicine is the four evidences and eight outlines, and the medicine of Chinese medicine is to come from nature ...... This is the norms of Chinese medicine, and the norms of Western medicine are two different things, and don't mix them up.

I wonder what it means to standardize Chinese medicine? Do we want to standardize the laws of nature? Say it rains, say it rains, say it windy, windy, so that the typhoon will not harm human beings, so the norms are too favorable. Modern Chinese medicine lost to the efficacy, not standardized, Chinese medicine according to the laws of nature, can not regulate the natural rules, can not regulate Chinese medicine.

The efficacy of Chinese medicine in treating diseases is excellent, but why can't it beat Western medicine? This has to start from the following aspects.

First, the backwardness of modern China is the main reason, the people of China who are afraid of being beaten are no longer confident in their own things. The greatness of the ship and the sharp artillery was learned by the people of the country began to think that that is advanced, only called science, so people began to worship the West.

In order to change the face of the motherland, a large number of students went abroad to study. Those elites who aspired to the West learned Western culture and returned home, they completely abandoned the things of the motherland. All of the Western set of things into China, the leadership positions are held by these people, Chinese medicine has been intentionally left out of the policy.

With the various screening equipment, ordinary diseases also need to spend a lot of money on screening. This benefit of generating revenue before treating a disease makes hospital leaders and doctors overjoyed.

The Chinese medicine practitioners' mode of taking pulse and then prescribing Chinese medicine can cure serious and difficult diseases, but each time they can only earn less than $50 for taking pulse and Chinese medicine. Compared with Western medicine, which can earn several thousand dollars in examination fees without curing the disease, it is really not desirable.

Young people are confused by the modern electronic technology, but also confused that the more new machinery, the more scientific. So they flock to western hospitals and do not look back, even if they get worse.

It is difficult to accept the thousands of years of unimproved healing modes, and it is troublesome and unpalatable to cook and drink those herbal medicines, not to mention the fact that some households do not have the conditions to cook them at all.

Slowly, for a variety of reasons, including the quality and counterfeiting of medicines, doctors' lack of interest in Chinese medicine, obstruction by interests, and a large number of media attacking Chinese medicine, Chinese medicine has fallen out of fashion.

The funny thing is that hospitals don't need to be too good at curing patients because it's hard to make money when they get well too fast. But patients should want to spend less money and can cure the disease, but they do not, is to fight to the death to support Western medicine to cripple themselves and then dry, there is such a market, but also doomed to let the Western medicine scenery.

I agree because there are many doctors in the private sector who can cure terminal cancer, and he or she is blocked by the Chinese Medicine Act from treating the sick and saving lives, but the patients do not recognize the License to Practice Medicine.

In my humble opinion, the development of Chinese medicine is fundamentally based on efficacy, and the key is in the standardization, which should promote the improvement of efficacy. A patient, ten Chinese medicine practitioners, ten prescriptions, efficacy are the same, always makes no sense. Chinese medicine system should be in line with the Chinese medicine thinking of the rationale and method of prescription norms, which is the general law, and the doctrine is a special law, the two are not contradictory, the premise of the exact efficacy of the treatment to save people's lives.

The focus of the discussion now is to standardize how to ensure the efficacy of Chinese medicine. In my humble opinion, we can start by familiarizing ourselves with the classics of Chinese medicine, start by flexibly applying the medical cases of Chinese medicine practitioners, and start from the patient's demand for treatment and health, and formulate corresponding diagnostic and treatment norms from the multi-dimensional aspects of class method, class evidence and class prescription, as a supplement to the existing Chinese medicine treatment guidelines compiled according to modern diseases.

Chinese medicine norms must be abiding, yin and yang meridian, five transport six gas, four gas five flavor, six meridian identification, eight program identification, viscera identification, triple jiao identification, gas, blood, fluid, phlegm, dampness, drink and stasis, etc., can not be thrown away, but always move forward, the development of the norms, there is no norms on how to deal with conflicts between doctors and patients, how to protect doctors, patients, the legitimate interests, and now some Chinese medicine clinics do not leave patients with a prescription, how to say it is not good enough. Chinese medicine should be standardized, the past teacher, there are disciples out of the master, not in the master of the rules of practicing medicine in the vicinity. Therefore, the regulation of Chinese medicine should be in line with the characteristics of Chinese medicine and should be based on the actual situation. A broad-brush approach is open to comment.

In my humble opinion, the regulation of Chinese medicine is necessary to promote the efficacy of Chinese medicine. On the contrary, any norms that are not conducive to improving the efficacy of Chinese medicine should be reformed and improved. Of course, the misconception of abolishing medicine and keeping medicine is even more undesirable.

I see that modern Chinese medicine has several major problems that must be overcome. First, there is a lack of common sense education for the young. It is a fact that some Chinese medicines are difficult to drink, and if you don't form a habit from a young age, you will think that it is too hard to drink Chinese medicine. Second, many people think that the effect of Chinese medicine is slow and have no patience to take it. Third, the interests of Chinese and Western medical practitioners compete fiercely, and ultimately, Chinese medicine has no say and must be defeated. Fourth, originally, the safety of Chinese herbal medicine for curing diseases is much better than Western medicine, however, Western medicine insists that modern times is a society of law and order, and Chinese medicine must have legal proof, and Chinese medicine is a complex medical process, based on experience, boldness, materialistic and dialectical thinking, meticulousness, insight and accuracy, to achieve a cure for diseases. Fifth, how can the examination questions of Chinese medicine certificate be standardized? Western medicine is standardized, one size fits all, but can TCM be standardized? But can TCM be standardized? Chinese medicine is characterized by the most flexible, the most important clinical experience, the most talk about enough to cure the rate (stopping the drug does not recur), therefore, Chinese medicine must be put on the treatment technology to test the certificate of the important position of the theory of the examination, the examination of medical ethics and medical regulations of Chinese medicine rules will be enough. Chinese medicine to develop, indeed is to keep the right innovation as a priority, the right things can not be lost, that is, following the past, to carry on the next, a famous doctor, a good medical skills of traditional Chinese medicine can not be no theoretical basis, but sometimes the right theory can also be created by themselves (theory of practice), to give Chinese medicine to an innovative spirit of space time, not at all suppressed, to encourage innovation and development of more advanced effect of the To encourage the innovation and development of more advanced effect of Chinese medicine theory, innovative results, to award special prizes, as with scientific and technological innovation. Therefore, the formulation of laws and regulations must also be in line with the characteristics of Chinese medicine, both to give space for development, but also to emphasize the effectiveness of Chinese medicine, regardless of Chinese medicine and Western medicine, but also to allow experimental failures, allow doctors to have some small faults, medicine in order to continue to develop (Prof. Chen Ping language), Prof. Chen Ping has a point, scientific research are allowed to fail, why can't medicine? Why can't medicine fail? How can there be success without mistakes? Without experience, there is vigilance. Of course, this is for doctors who study innovation.
In my opinion, Chinese medicine does not lose in efficacy (the treatment and reduction of the toxicity of the new crown pneumonia, realizing the effect of low toxicity and non-infectious), but in the public perception, in the patience to cure the disease, and in the physicochemical control of the Western medicine perception, trying to get a quick fix, ignoring the actual meaning of the medicine: integrality, wholeness, effectiveness, and stopping the medicine for long-lasting effect. I hope that the Chinese experience of C.pneumoniae can bring us a wake-up call and a thought, why Chinese medicine can overcome C.pneumoniae? What is the reason?

In modern society, technology is changing rapidly, modern medicine is deeply rooted in people's hearts, some people are still pushing the delusion that the ancient people's practice of curing the sick, ask what other industry is like this?

The problem with Chinese medicine is not efficacy and standardization, but how to make good use of modern science and medicine to play the role of complementary and supplementary medicine.

For example, in the case of advanced cancer, where modern medicine does not have a good solution and treatment is abandoned, comfort is given to the patient through Chinese medicine in order to alleviate the patient's anxiety towards death and to regulate the panic that there is no cure.

Chinese medicine can make a contribution and survive only if it is integrated into modern medicine and is a good supplement to modern medicine, and if the efficacy and safety of Chinese medicine are tested through scientific means.

Chinese medicine with Chinese medicine is with the symptoms, is based on the severity of the patient's condition, physical condition and decide the amount of medicine and the combination of heavy and heavy! It can not be prescribed! According to the norms of dispensing, only can not cure the disease! More by the Acura disease! Why nowadays the practitioners are eulogized, all more for this! There is more is not proficient to also! The use of medicine is like the use of soldiers, according to the actual battlefield and change! Ma Su and so the defeat, is the dead memorization of the book of war to! Well, no more 。。。。。。

Chinese medicine lost? How do I not feel, actually in the medical aspect of Chinese medicine is the strongest backing of the Chinese people, even Western doctors usually family have to boil some of this drink a drink, soak some of which drink a drink, to regulate the body balance and health care, every family in the country can not be separated, know more than mastered properly, a lifetime of not sick, not seen the usual who often boiled some of the Western medicines, soak some of the Western medicines to drink with the prevention of disease. Chinese medicine can also prevent and control the occurrence of major diseases, that is not called losing, is playing a big role in obscurity, habitual, commonplace, so inconspicuous, not dazzling, and eating, drinking and smoking, most families are equipped with a variety of traditional Chinese medicine particles, pills, punch and so on, a small Chinese medicine most know a little knowledge of the basic popularization of traditional Chinese medicine, Chinese medicine, Chinese medicine popularization of the Chinese countryside plays a great role! The popularization of traditional Chinese medicine plays a big role in rural China. Take the new crown epidemic this time, basically did not happen in the countryside, but in the big cities.

Haha, who doesn't want to "rule the world for thousands of years"? It's good to laugh, just laugh and not say anything.

This question and answer are from the site users, does not represent the position of the site, such as infringement, please contact the administrator to delete.

Related Questions