Some people say that Chinese medicine is Chinese medicine and Western medicine is Western medicine, and that combining Chinese and Western medicine is a mistake, what do you think about this?
Some people say that Chinese medicine is Chinese medicine and Western medicine is Western medicine, and that combining Chinese and Western medicine is a mistake, what do you think about this?
I have a sore throat, prescribing medicine is their own as a Chinese medicine brother-in-law, Chinese doctors prescribe Western medicine, the combination of Chinese and Western perfect success, I keenly feel the throat loosened.
Time belongs to the qigong spread as spring on stage, such as enjoying too jail, and even Liu Huan to sing to the leader is also spitting to collect the momentum, Huang Di Nei Jing in the high man in general, the whole audience applauded, today's Liu Huan full of white hair, holding clutches.
My sister was curious to ask me about qigong methods, and my brother-in-law, who was a doctor in the first line, rebuked me, and my sister and I never had another conversation about qigong.
First-line Chinese medicine practitioners do not believe in qigong, and Chinese medicine is indeed lost. There is no source of living water for Chinese medicine without qigong, and there should be a combination of Chinese and Western medicine.
Huang Di Nei Jing is a vast Chinese medicine masterpiece, the magic gas to administer poison, Taoist gas detoxification, drinking Chinese medicine, on a trip to the outhouse, refreshing, can be said that Chinese medicine soldiers great victory, a song of escaping from the people of the Tang Dynasty and Song Dynasty.
Heart to tongue, ear to kidney, liver to wood, ready to week is meant to be dangerous, common is not doubt, the sun taiyin, ancient Chinese medicine can go through the twelve meridians to see the patient's disease, medicine to the disease, abiding by the great doctor of sincerity, the great mansion door to talk about the Chinese medicine, chaotic world of the great pseudo in the wisdom. The idea of Chinese medicine is the Tao Te Ching in all things negative Yin and hold Yang, Chong Qi thought and, Chinese medicine famous doctor attributes of the wonders of the world.
Ancient herbalists were also soldiers.
Western medicine with instruments can easily see the patient's lesions, Chinese medicine has decades of power before the Ming Zhaqiu, and even Chinese medicine state is not stable. So the lack of internal health of Chinese medicine lack of soul, scientific judgment qigong does not exist, so Chinese medicine doctors do not come out of the blue Chinese medicine doctors are familiar with the Huangdi Neijing national treasure.
When the product comes out of a doctor who is only suited for Western medicine, the combination of Western and Chinese medicine is actually Western medicine.
Chinese medicine that lacks qigong is actually Western medicine.
Personally, I believe that the combination of Chinese and Western medicine initially refers to the clinical combination, that is, the disease can be treated by Western medicine methods and also by Chinese medicine methods. It is the result of mutual tolerance. It is not a mistake, if you want to say that it is a mistake, it is the later people who have misunderstood and misguided. In addition, Chinese medicine is suitable for training from a young age, at least from junior high school, with a master-apprentice system. The same should be true for Western medicine. Just like the art of opera, it is too late to wait until high school graduation to learn it, because the best period of human memory has already passed.
Chinese medicine and Western medicine are two different cultures and national habits, they can cooperate can complement each other, can not be combined, if combined will be like a donkey and a horse as the offspring is not like a donkey or a horse and fertility.
Chinese and Western medicine can be combined!!!! In the 1970's, when I was with my teacher, many patients were taking both Chinese and Western medicines, and the results were good! At that time, patients wanted to be cured quickly! So both Chinese and Western medicines were prescribed! (Workers, commercial workers) mostly! The older generation, the cadres, usually took decoctions of Chinese medicine! Western medicines are used for emergencies and unknown symptoms! I think a combination of Chinese and Western medicines can work! But it's better to have the same doctor for both Chinese and Western medicines! Doctors nowadays are not practicing as much as they should! That's why it's not effective! If you study deeply, the combination of Chinese and Western medicine is feasible! For general organic diseases, Chinese medicine is good!!! For bacterial diseases, Western medicine is good!!! The combination of Chinese and Western medicine must be clear about its pharmacology!!! The result will be better! All day long, Chinese-Chinese, Western-Western, discussions come and go!!! It's meaningless indeed! Practice makes perfect, that's the best answer!!!!
An analogy.
You can't eat vegetables without eating meat, and you can't eat vegetables without eating meat.
-Stupid? Stupid? Stupid? Stupid?
--Isn't it silly to compete with your own life and health?
Has anyone seen this?
Can a pseudoscience persist and flourish for thousands of years?
Have you ever thought about.
How is it that a continual civilization that has lasted for thousands of years, with one-fifth of the world's population, happens to be a nation that is wedded to Chinese medicine (and not to Western medicine - no disparagement intended)?
Chinese medicine black--
There is no fear in ignorance!
The combination of Chinese and Western medicine is an ideal and aspiration that can be combined in clinical applications and can play a complementary role in the treatment of many diseases.
However, they contradict each other in terms of ideas and theories, and can be said to be incompatible. Standing in the position of Western medicine, absolutely deny the theory of Chinese medicine, and even think that the theory of Chinese medicine is the product of the ancient period of ignorance, mixed with too much dross, should be eliminated; Standing in the position of Chinese medicine, will think that the Western medical treatment is in the wrong direction, headache, foot pain, can not really solve the problem.
Therefore, the combination of Chinese and Western medicines should be studied in terms of the way of combining them, rather than remaining on the top of slogans or combining them in a haphazard manner. For example: in the pCms add western medicines, if there is evidence to prove that the mixture of the two 1 + 1 is greater than the effect of 2 is also not bad, but in fact the creation of an excuse to raise the price of medicines, and does not really reflect the original intention of the combination of Chinese and Western medicine, the current combination of Chinese and Western medicine is mainly embodied in the process of treatment of the disease, and each to give full play to their own strengths.
The technical combination of Chinese and Western medicine is low-level, the only way to stand in the direction of the future of medicine and realize "Culture of Life"vs."life sciences"Integration is the way of the future of human medicine.
01. Chinese and Western medicine can be meticulously combined. But, ultimately"Oil is oil, water is water.."
The Spring and Autumn Annals of Yanzi - Question No. 18: "If one does not meticulously combine to conceal one's loyalty, it can be said that one does not lose one's loyalty; if one does not hold a profit to injure one's integrity, it can be said that one does not lose one's conduct." Between Chinese and Western medicine, it is possible to combine meticulously. However, this kind of integration is not free from the suspicion of pandering or harmonizing.
Combining the knowledge and methods of traditional Chinese medicine with those of Western medicine and Western drugs, on the basis of improving clinical efficacy, technical combination, just like Chinese people wearing suits, not impossible. It's just that no matter how you wear it, it doesn't look as handsome as Westerners wear it.
Similarly, no matter how close TCM practitioners are to Western medicine, they cannot show that they are superior.
The reason lies in the fact that the learning behind the knowledge, the way behind the method, the theoretical structure and the logic of thinking in this are fundamentally different, as if putting "Oil of Chinese Medicine"Put in."Water for Western Medicine"Inside, fromphysical spaceLook, it's resting together, but "in the heart of humanity"It's hard to blend in.lit. heart and hands cannot touch each other (idiom); fig. two hearts cannot meet as oneWhere's the real science in that?
02. Integrative medicine has its own market and value of existence.
The discipline of Chinese and Western medicine, as a non-first-class discipline, has a certain market and value of existence. It is undeniable that the integration of Chinese and Western medicine has been a long-term policy practiced by the Chinese government since 1949. As a cross-discipline between Chinese and Western medicine, the integration of Chinese and Western medicine started from clinical practice and gradually evolved into an academic system with clear development goals and unique methodology, it still has a certain market and exploratory value.
03.“lit. pull Lang Lang (idiom); fig. marriage between two people who are mutually exclusive"The days are not far gone.
Chinese medicine has more thinking dimensions than Western medicine, and Western medicine has a lower thinking interface than Chinese medicine. The theoretical contradictions in thinking between Chinese and Western medicine are said to be, if in terms of logical derivation, "lit. incompatible as fire and water", is not too much.
Chinese medicine is the popularization of Chinese life culture or the original survival, life, production and life survival of the national flower blooming on the soil, if in the case of Chinese medicine common sense and general knowledge popularization shortage, stand in the position of Western medicine, do not recognize and deny Chinese medicine is inevitable.
This inevitable embarrassment may even stubbornly suggest that Chinese medicine is a sign of non-civilization, or that the so-called dross far outweighs the essence. But, after all, the Western medicine kind of "treat the symptoms rather than getting to the root of the problem (proverb)"The strange phenomenon, obviously can not solve the problem from the root, but also contrary to the common sense of ordinary people's lives, its actually have a few points of real scientific wisdom content, really suspicious.
04.“Oil-water combination model"Easily alienated into"lit. dredge for oil"The Deal.
In the pCms inside the addition of Western medicines, the two mixed whether to achieve "1 + 1 is greater than 2", often is not known, but the reality, to the drugstores to raise the price of drugs for the grand reason, this cloak of legalization, unscrupulous, multiply the risk of profiteering, not to be taken lightly.
05. Humanistic general medicine is a major trend in the future of medicine.
Both Chinese medicine and Western medicine have only explored part of the causes of disease, and according to the existing degree of awakening of humanistic culture, they have not been able to reveal all or the essential causes of disease.
If Western medicine can be viewed from the perspective of life sciences, and if Chinese medicine can be viewed from the perspective of the culture of life, these twoone yin and one yangIntegrate together, that is, science to humanities close to, humanities to science close to. Let the vague Chinese medicine more intuitive, let the cold Western medicine more human temperature. In this wayNegative yin, embracing yang, and integrating the body, forming a new dynamic of humanistic general medicine.worthy of hope。
This is not only conducive to helping patients find the true nature of the cause of their illness, but also to creating a more humane atmosphere for health prevention and management with a view to:
Returning unhealthy people to the normalcy of life as it should be.
To make life more dignified.
A better future for mankind.
Day is day and night is, in opposition to each other, different after all. A day has day and night, together is a day, so unified and harmonious. Chinese medicine and Western medicine, after all, different, each with its own strengths and weaknesses, in order to save the lives of the people, therefore, with its long to avoid its short, so unified and coordinated.
--After the discovery of various mutated viruses in the world epidemic, it was found that Western medicine is the main culprit of the mutated viruses, so there is no need to combine Chinese medicine with Western medicine, and the combination of Chinese medicine and Western medicine is actually a mistake.

They can only work with each other, not in combination.
This question and answer are from the site users, does not represent the position of the site, such as infringement, please contact the administrator to delete.