1. Home
  2. Question details

Which do you support more, modern medicine or traditional medicine?

Which do you support more, modern medicine or traditional medicine?

Support is left to those who have the ability and economic strength, on the treatment of health care I choose to benefit my Chinese medicine, with a good kitchen onion, ginger, garlic, pepper and other minor ailments do not commit, with a good everywhere there are dozens of grasses such as Chaihu dandelion septoria, and other major ailments can not afford to commit, each with their own beliefs and pursuits and good, the most practical or live well, the best.

I support all of them. But the questioner asked about "more", so, without a doubt, I would support "modern medicine".

Any sane person would be the first to go in favor of modern medicine. This has nothing to do with any national feelings, nothing to do with any cultural feelings, but with the human right to life.

It is very simple, when you are faced with a major disease which is fatal to you, do you choose modern medicine or traditional medicine? I think that even the strongest supporters of traditional medicine, in the face of life and death decisions, they will not hesitate to choose modern medicine first. Because, modern medicine can save their lives! If you don't believe me, you can go to investigate those old famous doctors who inherited traditional medicine, they are suffering from major diseases or facing a life and death crisis, is it the same choice of modern medicine to save them?

Even though modern medicine has not yet been developed to perfection, there are still defects, and it cannot cure all diseases, modern medicine still surpasses traditional medicine in terms of efficacy, and modern medicine is still in the process of continuous progress. Now some diseases can not be completely solved by modern medicine, but science is progress, now can not be solved, does not mean that 30 years later, 50 years later, 100 years later can not be solved. Even if it can't be solved after 100 years, we can still wait for 200 years, 300 years, 500 years. One day, it will all be solved by the problem. Traditional medicine, on the other hand, has basically come to a standstill, and even if traditional medicine may still evolve, it is very limited. This is because traditional medicine derives more from culture than from practice. The practice of traditional medicine, naturally, exists, but for one thing, subjective experience is not always reliable, and for another, there are problems with its empirical methods.

In my opinion, it is not necessary to kill traditional medicine with a single stroke, and it is also necessary to recognize that it may contain some beneficial things, some of which may also be beneficial to health care. However, we should have a clear choice about what is light and what is heavy. It is clear which is the lesser or the greater.


I certainly support modern medicine!

There is no denying that modern medicine cannot cure all diseases either, but it is an indisputable fact that modern medicine has become an integral part of human life. For example, since the X-ray, human beings faced with a fracture, can soon find the specific part of the fracture and the specific degree of injury. And with ultrasound and CT, it is even possible to know the internal condition of the human body without having to undergo surgery, thus greatly reducing the patient's pain, the risk of infection and the chance of death. These are extremely common diagnostic tools used in modern medicine! There are hardly a few people who have not used these means to diagnose their conditions.

And more and more traditional medicine-oriented hospitals have begun to accept the views of modern medicine and utilize modern medical means to diagnose conditions. They even recommend patients to modern medicine-based hospitals for treatment when they really can't treat them themselves. Therefore, believing in modern medicine is also part of believing in modern science. And blindly stick to the old rut, cover up the ears and think that traditional things can solve all the problems. It is really a ridiculous thing. To put it over the top, without modern technology, you and I can't even argue!

It is certainly more important to support modern medicine, after all, human life and health is not a small matter, surely we should choose the more scientific modern medicine.

Modern medicine has developed step by step from traditional medicine, absorbing the essence of traditional medicine and discarding many of the dregs of traditional medicine. Traditional things should be inherited and discarded, culture should be preserved and bad habits should be discarded.

For example, in the earlier days, there were also many unscientific practices in western traditional medicine, such as when one was sick, it was assumed that there was an excess of certain components in the blood and one needed to pull the mouth and let some blood out. And of course these treatments may have worked for some people, but many more people perished in this traditional medicine. So these are traditions that just need to go into museums so that people can learn about the past.

Modern medicine is medicine supported and armed by contemporary science and technology, and it is believed that when a person is in a life-threatening crisis, the first choice is modern medicine. Traditional medicine can also play a role in rehabilitation and wellness, but should not be indulged in.

Some people on the Internet who threaten to abandon modern medicine are just having a good time. When there is a serious illness or emergency, he will still choose modern medicine, for example, when a child is born, he will still choose to deliver the child in a hospital and get vaccinated, which is impossible in a modern society to get away from modern medicine.

I. My views support modern medicine

If I had to pick one, then I am unquestionably in favor of modern medicine! Since I am in western medicine myself, the uncontroversial conclusion is that I support modern medicine! This is because modern medicine is more rigorous, more controlled, safer, and more effective!

II. Supporting Western medicine does not mean rejecting Chinese medicine

Modern medicine has a lot to learn and draw on, and Chinese medicine also has its strengths that need to be drawn on, such as the holistic view of Chinese medicine, the treatment of diseases before they occur in Chinese medicine, acupuncture in Chinese medicine, and so on, which is also a treasure that should not be underestimated! Therefore, supporting Western medicine does not mean that we have to abandon Chinese medicine. Rather, we have to learn from each other's strengths and abandon each other's shortcomings in order to have a better space and prospect for development!

Third, it is actually the "Chinese medicine practitioners" who have screwed up Chinese medicine.

There are a lot of Chinese medicine under the banner of the big fool, playing the cure-all disease "experts", under the guise of not taking drugs and surgery "cowman", is the biggest scourge of Chinese medicine! Moreover, there is no standard for TCM to be considered, which is also the biggest obstacle to its stagnation! You have to ask the best formula, even thousands of years ago, the ancient formula, this, with the theory of evolution does not seem to explain! Therefore, in order to develop, the need to break through is not Western medicine, but Chinese medicine itself!

As a doctor specializing in Chinese medicine, I agree that Western medicine and Chinese medicine have their own strengths, and the key is how to rationally apply them in different areas. Some diseases should be treated with Western medicine, some with Chinese medicine, and some with interaction.

If a serious infectious disease affects the cardiopulmonary function and the life is threatened, of course, one should choose Western medicine, which has a series of first aid theories and measures such as acid-base balance, water-electrolyte balance, and the monitoring of vital signs, etc. These are a series of techniques embodying modern science and technology that Chinese medicine cannot hope to achieve. There is also the widespread use of surgical techniques and the prevention of infectious diseases. Although Western medicine has made great achievements, but behind these great achievements can not hide its inherent defects.

Western medicine is evidence-based medicine, the entity structure of the study of the meticulous, the purpose is to want to put things infinitely subdivided, trying to find out the causes of disease, in fact, such a research idea anti-Western medicine to the quagmire of the inextricable, we must know that the human body and the universe of the entity and the virtual structure of the body exists at the same time, and indivisible, the epistemology of the Western medicine violates the most basic dialectic, so with the virtual structure of the diseases related to the Western medicine can not be any advantage. may have any advantage.

Meridians are imaginary structures in the human body that coexist with entities and are objective immaterial existences. The meridian system is a great discovery of the ancients, and its description is very precise, reflecting the high wisdom of the ancients, and the pragmatic spirit of high responsibility for future generations. The perfect meridian theory has been guiding the clinical acupuncture and massage clinics.

Chinese medicine has accumulated a wealth of experience in the study of meridian laws, which makes it dominant in the treatment of many chronic diseases, such as: headache, neck and shoulder pain, low back pain, joint pain, chronic cough, chronic pharyngitis, and many kinds of chronic internal diseases are much more powerful than Western medicine.

Walking on two legs, better than one leg of the limp line, the combination of Chinese and Western medicine, is the people's needs, the inevitable trend of historical development, the relationship between the two is complementary, organic combination, rather than each other tilting, dismantling of the stage, the patient is greatly beneficial.

Which one do you support, the Goddess of Mercy or the Goddess of Mercy who saves people from suffering?

There is no doubt in favor of modern medicine, which has tremendous advantages, both in its understanding of life and in its understanding of the onset and regression of disease, and traditional medicine, although it can cure diseases, has great limitations.

In ancient times, people in various regions and countries would also get sick and have the need to improve their health, so they each had various attempts to find some plants and animal medicinal herbs, or use some physical and chemical means to make up for the deficiencies of the human body, and gradually developed traditional medicine. Although they gained experience in treating some diseases for a long time, they did not have enough knowledge about the causes of diseases and so on, and there were a lot of misunderstandings about the treatments for certain diseases. There are many misconceptions about the treatment of certain diseases.

The absorption of some medicines in traditional medicine is also not well ensured, and the treatment of diseases may also be slow and require long-term medication to achieve certain effects. Modern medicine, on the other hand, by studying the metabolic characteristics of the human body to manufacture drugs, can be better absorbed by the human body, but also can take certain measures to make the drug released slowly, in a longer period of time to play a role.

The limitations of traditional medicine is not only in the drug, but also in the lack of knowledge of the human body, anatomy, molecular biology, genetics, virology and other disciplines of the development of the human body more clearly, intuitively recognize the causes of disease, so that the "Western medicine" metamorphosis into modern medicine, can be more targeted to solve the human body diseases, from the symptoms, etiology of the start! The development of "Western medicine" has made the human body more clearly and intuitively recognize the causes of diseases, so that "Western medicine" is transformed into modern medicine, which can solve human diseases in a more targeted way, and start from the symptoms and causes of diseases.

This question is like asking a chess master: is the knight or the cannon better? In fact, who is better depends entirely on the player. As a doctor, both Chinese medicine and Western medicine are our means of treating diseases, and both Chinese and Western medicine have their own advantages. If a patient suffers from lymphoma, chemotherapy is definitely the mainstay of western medicine, and when the patient suffers from anemia, fatigue and other symptoms of deficiency of qi and blood after several chemotherapy sessions, it is feasible to give the Chinese medicine Bazhen Tang with additional reduction to enhance the patient's physique. Of course, some chronic diseases can also be based on traditional Chinese medicine to identify and treat. Depending on the patient's situation, we can choose to Western medicine or Chinese medicine. Li Yuanba is good at using hammer and Li Kui is good at using axe, but we can't say whether the hammer is good or the axe is good, the key is how to use it and when to use it. It is hoped that Chinese and Western medical practitioners will complement each other's strengths and weaknesses instead of attacking each other, for this will be conducive to the development of medicine.

This question and answer are from the site users, does not represent the position of the site, such as infringement, please contact the administrator to delete.

Related Questions